Showing posts with label euthanasia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label euthanasia. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 5, 2010

Liberty Trumps Life

The right to life is more important than right to liberty.

Spitzer's Argument
I just finished listening to part one of an insightful audio presentation by Robert Spitzer SJ. Father Spitzer points out our three fundamental and inalienable rights that include:
  1. Right to life
  2. Right to liberty
  3. Right to property
Spitzer draws part of this information from philosopher John Locke, and the United States constitution.
Ranking Inalienable Rights
Father Spitzer argues that the importance of a right is directly related to the damage that is done when that right is denied. If you deny someones right to life, then that person doesn't have to worry about his/her liberty or property. So, right to life is the most important right. We can see the truth of this if we image denying the second fundamental right of liberty. Someone who is not free doesn't have to worry about owning any property. So, liberty is a more important right than owning property.
Euthanasia Denys the Most Important Inalienable Right
Among the reasons given to end the life of someone who is terminally ill is the complaint that the medical bills accrued, and the needed care giving put a burden on the person's family. In short it is a complaint that the family's liberty is being denied. So, by ending the ill persons life they are denying his/her right to life. This is done so the family can regain its liberty. This is selfish, and morally wrong.

Monday, January 4, 2010

Dehumanization

Celebrating practices like abortion, assisted suicide, and euthanasia emerge from the conscious choice of dehumanizing what are truly human beings.

Beginnings
Abortion was the first step in the process of dehumanizing unborn babies. At the center of the abortion debate is the question whether the fetus is a human being. When the decisions was made to kill babies in the womb it was because the unborn child was determined to be less than human. The popular linguistic word game goes "we are not killing a baby--we are only terminating a pregnacy." So, first the unborn were less than human.

The Progression
The next step in the process was to say that terminally ill people are no longer humans; because of their illnesses, their lives are open to be murdered. It is because of the burdens that these illnesses place on family members that is used to justify that the terminally ill do not really deserve to live. This means the value of life is measured by what it contributes rather than being measured for what it is. This unacceptable mercenary approach to human appraisel is repugnent.

If you doubt the reality of the scenario I am laying out, you only need to look at the Netherlands. Assisted suicide is legal for the Dutch in cases of terminal illness. In practice, by legalizing assisted suicide it has opened a door to the non-voluntary euthanasia of patients who doctors label unworthy of living. Any who rest in the comfort that the language of a law will protect them from medical murder need to wake from their dream-like state.

Tribalism
The pattern of dehumanizing certain people reminds me of the tribalism and genocide we saw in the twentieth century. In Rwanda, if you were from the wrong tribe you could be murdered and were in essence not considered human. The same practice happened in the Balkans.

The Nazi's dehumanized the Jews, and thereby wrongly eased their consciences of murder of those they no longer considered fellow human beings. Sadly, few of us have bothered to learn about such horrid events, and that makes it impossible to learn the critical lessons of history.